# Clean Architecture — Deep Reference Based on Robert C. Martin, *Clean Architecture* (2017). Use this when you need detailed criteria for dependency direction, layers, and boundaries. ## Dependency Rule **Dependencies point inward only.** Code in the center (entities, use cases) must not depend on code in outer circles (UI, DB, frameworks). Outer circles depend on inner circles; inner circles define interfaces, outer circles implement them. - **Violation**: A use case that imports from Express, Django, or a concrete repository implementation. - **Correct**: Use case depends on an interface (e.g., `OrderRepository`); the adapter in the outer layer implements it and uses Express/DB. ## Layers (from inside out) 1. **Entities** — Enterprise business rules. Plain structures and rules that apply across the application. No dependencies on frameworks or UI. 2. **Use cases** — Application business rules. Orchestrate entities and define application-specific workflows. Depend only on entities and on interfaces for I/O (repositories, presenters). 3. **Interface adapters** — Convert data between use cases and the outside world. Presenters, gateways, controllers that translate external format to/from use-case format. Depend on use cases (and entities only via use cases). 4. **Frameworks and drivers** — Web framework, DB driver, messaging, file I/O. Implement interfaces defined by use cases or interface adapters. Depend inward. ## Boundaries - **Boundary** = interface or abstract type that inner code depends on; outer code implements. - Good boundaries make it easy to swap implementations (e.g., in-memory repo for tests, SQL repo for production). - Draw boundaries where there is a reason to vary or replace (different persistence, different UI, different transport). ## SOLID in this context - **SRP** — Each module (class/package) has one reason to change (one actor). E.g., separate "report formatting" from "report calculation" if they change for different reasons. - **OCP** — Extend behavior via new implementations of interfaces (new adapters), not by editing existing use-case or entity code. - **LSP** — Any implementation of a repository or gateway interface must be substitutable without breaking the use case. - **ISP** — Small, focused interfaces (e.g., `ReadOrderRepository` and `WriteOrderRepository` if read and write evolve differently) instead of one fat `OrderRepository`. - **DIP** — Use cases depend on `OrderRepository` (interface); the composition root wires in `SqlOrderRepository`. High-level policy does not depend on low-level details. ## Inversion of dependencies - **Without inversion**: Use case imports and calls `SqlOrderRepository` directly → use case depends on DB. - **With inversion**: Use case depends on `OrderRepository` (interface); `SqlOrderRepository` implements it and is injected at the edge. Use case stays independent of SQL. ## Component cohesion and coupling (for larger systems) When grouping classes into **components** (modules, packages), Uncle Bob defines: **Cohesion:** - **REP (Reuse/Release Equivalence)** — The unit of reuse is the unit of release; group classes that are reused and released together. - **CCP (Common Closure)** — Classes that change for the same reasons belong in the same component; reduces impact of change. - **CRP (Common Reuse)** — Classes reused together should be packaged together; avoid forcing dependents to pull in more than they need. **Coupling:** - **ADP (Acyclic Dependencies)** — Component dependency graph must have no cycles. - **SDP (Stable Dependencies)** — Depend in the direction of stability; less stable components depend on more stable ones. - **SAP (Stable Abstractions)** — Stable components should be abstract; unstable components can be concrete. Use this when discussing module/package boundaries beyond single layers. For full treatment see *Clean Architecture* (Martin, 2017). --- Use this reference when reviewing for "dependency direction," "layer violations," or "missing boundaries."